Friday, April 5, 2013

We Beat Chevron, but the Fight for Real Justice Continues

Reposted from Eye on the Amazon

We Beat Chevron, but the Fight for Real Justice Continues

At one point or another every social justice activist wakes up wondering if we stand a chance against the massive forces acting against us. This week, my faith in justice was given a boost when Amazon Watch won a major victory in the face of Chevron's massive legal efforts against us. In U.S. Federal Court on Wednesday, Chevron's efforts to significantly disrupt our work and threaten our ability to campaign against their reprehensible actions in Ecuador were entirely quashed.

Several months ago I wrote about being served a subpoena on my front doorstep by one of Chevron's 60 law firms – Gibson Dunn & Crutcher. Chevron has falsely accused Amazon Watch of participating in a "massive global conspiracy" against the company because we have stood with the communities fighting for justice in Ecuador for almost two decades. As part of their scorched earth legal strategy, Chevron is attacking virtually anyone and everyone who has spoken out about Chevron's misdeeds in Ecuador. As this post by our heroic legal support team at EarthRights International explains, "Chevron has also sought discovery from journalists, activists, lawyers, and even from its own shareholders."

Yet, even after obtaining hundreds of thousands of documents from other parties and hundred of hours of depositions, they had not a shred of evidence that Amazon Watch has done anything wrong. Of course not. Because we haven't.

But we have had the nerve speak out year after year about their crimes and to organize shareholder pressure to push for responsible action. That's why in court our lawyer proudly referred to us as Chevron's "sharpest critic." What Chevron has actually sought to do is strip the communities in Ecuador of an ally in their fight, but Amazon Watch is not about to abandon our partners – those communities brave enough to take on the second largest oil company in the United States – and win.

There have been major setbacks in efforts to control corporate power in a post-Citizens United America. Imagine the consequences if large corporations were able to force those working hardest to keep them accountable to turn over all their contacts, private information, strategies and internal communications.

During Wednesday's hearing Ethan Dettmer, Chevron's lawyer from Gibson Dunn, specifically cited Amazon Watch as having created "petitions and demonstrations" as acts threatening to Chevron. Thankfully, their attorney was shut down mid-sentence by Judge Cousins who told him told that those are exactly the free speech rights we must protect.

Never forget: This entire legal effort is designed to keep the world from remembering the truth about Chevron in Ecuador. From remembering what Amazon Watch has been saying, and will continue to say to investors and shareholders, the media, governments, and communities everywhere – that Chevron:

  • Deliberately dumped billions of gallons of toxic foundation waters into the pristine Amazon rainforest over the course of decades.
  • Chose to pollute the rivers and streams and created a massive health crisis for the indigenous and local communities.
  • Has never accepted responsibility for their acts or taken effective efforts to clean up their waste nor to assist the tens of thousands who suffer from the contaminated environment.

We won a great victory in court this week, but we didn't win anything for those still suffering from Chevron's actions. We didn't win clean water, we didn't win improved health care, we didn't win a full-scale remediation of the toxic sludge Chevron deliberately dumped. But we did preserve our right to continue to pressure Chevron with the truth of their actions. We did preserve our ability to exercise our right to free speech and to be a watchdog against corporate crimes. That right is vital to protect the power of the people in our society. We will exercise that right until we DO win the things Amazonian communities in Ecuador need most.

Yes, Chevron can throw millions of dollars and thousands of lawyers at the problem and hope that they escape justice. They can overwhelm, bully, and intimidate critics by their sheer size and wealth. But this week they learned they won't always get away with it.

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Victory! Judge Thwarts Chevron's Attempt to Open Amazon Watch's Confidential Files

Reposted from EarthRights International

Yesterday, in a major victory for our friends at Amazon Watch (AW) and ERI’s legal team, a Federal Judge in California quashed two sweeping subpoenas issued to AW by Chevron Corporation. ERI, serving as AW’s lawyers, successfully argued that the subpoenas violated Amazon Watch’s First Amendment rights and were unduly burdensome and intended to harass one of Chevron’s public critics.

Amazon Watch is a nonprofit organization dedicated to promoting justice for indigenous groups in the Amazon. For more than a decade, Amazon Watch has been publicly critical of Chevron’s legacy of pollution, which has harmed the health and the environment of thousands of villagers in the Ecuadorian Amazon. The subpoenas sought AW’s internal documents and testimony related to its advocacy campaign against Chevron.

Since December, ERI has been defending Amazon Watch against Chevron’s effort to gain access to Amazon Watch’s campaign playbook. The task hasn’t always been easy, since ERI and Amazon Watch were up against Chevron’s army of lawyers.

The subpoenas were issued in connection with Chevron’s efforts to avoid an $18 billion judgment issued in 2011 by a court in Ecuador against the company for dumping toxic waste into Amazon waterways used by indigenous groups for drinking water. Chevron has refused to pay. Instead, it filed a civil racketeering (RICO) suit in New York against the Ecuadorian Plaintiffs, their counsel, and other individuals involved in the effort to hold Chevron accountable, claiming a global conspiracy to obtain a fraudulent judgment against Chevron. According to Chevron, this "global conspiracy" includes, academics, New York State officials, environmental consultants, activists, law firms, indigenous communities and two Ecuadorian courts.

As part of its lawsuit in New York, Chevron has sought intrusive discovery from those, including AW, who have dared to speak out about its activities in the Amazon. It has already received unprecedented discovery from parties to the litigation and a number of non-parties. The company has issued more than 100 subpoenas requesting documents and already conducted more than 320 hours of depositions, including more than 16 days from Steven Donziger, the alleged mastermind of the "conspiracy." Chevron has also sought discovery from journalists, activists, lawyers, and even from its own shareholders.

Although Chevron has falsely branded Amazon Watch as a "co-conspirator," Chevron could not and cannot provide any evidence of wrongdoing by Amazon Watch. Indeed, Amazon Watch has done no more than participate in an advocacy campaign critical of Chevron – exactly what the First Amendment protects.

Yesterday, the court in San Francisco reminded Chevron of this simple truth. Ruling from the bench to quash Chevron’s subpoenas, U.S. Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins said he had to balance the First Amendment rights of Amazon Watch against Chevron’s alleged need for discovery, and noted that Chevron had not tailored its requests to avoid infringing on AW’s free speech rights.

ERI awaits Magistrate Judge Cousins’s written ruling.

Take That Chevron: There's A First Amendment After All

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

Chevron took a severe punch yesterday in its home state of California when a judge there ruled to ditch the oil giant's subpoena against an environmental group that has been highly critical of the company concerning its massive contamination of the Ecuadorian rainforest. See the Reuters story here.

"I must err on the side of protecting the First Amendment activity," wrote California Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins.

The subpoena request results from a Chevron lawsuit in a New York court, where the company is arguing that Amazon Watch and others, including Chevron's own shareholders, are part of a grand conspiracy to "extort" money from it by applying public pressure through protests, advocacy in front of elected officials and negative media coverage.

Memo to Chevron: The First Amendment is in the Bill of Rights.

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Chevron Can Solve Its Argentina Problem: Pay the Judgment

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

Chevron's head of operations in Argentina has complained to the Ecuadorians, who recently won a $19 billion judgment against the company for massive oil contamination, that future exploration and drilling is threatened in Argentina because of a local court's decision to freeze its assets.

Efe News Service quoted Miguel Galluccio, Chevron's guy in the South American country, warning that the freeze resulting directly from Chevron's refusal to pay the Ecuador judgment "is absolutely detrimental to Argentina and could have a negative effect on investment."

Ok, Miguel, then convince your company to pay the judgment. You've got the money. It's that simple. Problem solved.

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

More Chevron Spies & Lies

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

This Huffington Post blog is the stuff of spy novels and would be hard to believe if it all hadn't been so well-documented.

In the blog, Karen Hinton offers up a compilation of some of the dirty tricks played by Chevron's private investigative firms that have been hired to discredit the $19 billion judgment against the company for oil contamination.

A short excerpt reads:

The Chevron Corporation has spied and – perhaps is still spying – on the Republic of Ecuador, fueling a fierce battle between the oil giant and President Rafael Correa, who is calling on other South American countries to hold Chevron accountable for the world's largest oil-related disaster in the Ecuadorian rainforest.

Fearing the loss of an historic, long-running environmental lawsuit in the Ecuadorian rainforest in 2009, Chevron secretly videotaped the judge hearing the case – with a spy pen and spy watch – in an effort to derail the trial by entrapping him, government officials and indigenous community leaders in a faked bribery scandal.

It goes without saying that if Chevron had been caught trying to secretly videotape a U.S. judge, it would be facing criminal charges.

Read the entire blog here.