Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Note to Chevron: Your Trial Lawyers at Gibson Dunn Need Some Serious Help

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

It is becoming increasingly clear that Chevron's high-priced legal team in the $19 billion Ecuador case lacks basic trial skills.

One of the most intriguing sights in the three-day hearing last week in New York on a discovery dispute related to the case was not the fact Chevron trucked in about 35 lawyers for the event.

It was that with 35 lawyers backing them up, the lead lawyers for Chevron – Randy Mastro and Andrea Neumann – seemed so disorganized and out of sorts.

They looked like what they are: corporate lawyers representing a big oil company trying to crush its indigenous victims and their lawyers.

That can't be good for Chevron.

Judge Lewis A. Kaplan will no doubt use the hearing to further script the RICO trial in Chevron's favor by prohibiting the use of almost all evidence that makes Chevron look bad. Judge Kaplan, who was unanimously reversed once in the case, already ruled that the extensive evidence of Chevron's contamination in Ecuador – evidence that proves the case was decidedly not a fraud – cannot be discussed in court.

Judge Kaplan is now well on the way to throwing out counterclaims from Steven Donziger (a longtime lawyer for the Ecuadorians) that outline a chilling tale of Chevron's environmental crimes in Ecuador, fraud, lies, espionage, and cover-up. Again, Judge Kaplan apparently does not have the guts to let the truth come out.

But even show trials don't always go according to plan.

Both Mastro and Neumann seemed to fall over themselves in court, at times infuriating Judge Kaplan.

Mastro repeatedly made speeches before he asked his questions, prompting Kaplan to repeatedly sustain objections. Mastro would then try to reframe his questions, but had trouble figuring out how.

After one of his speeches, Judge Kaplan asked Mastro: “Sir, is there a part of that treatise from which you want to ask a question?”

Neumann appeared as charming as the class nerd who takes notes and regurgitates them back on the next multiple choice test. She read her questions from a thick binder, imposing a form of slow torture on the court by going page by page without adjusting depending on what the witness said or how the court reacted.

Kaplan repeatedly asked her to stop wasting the court's time.

Neumann began her examination of one witness by reading from a sworn declaration signed by the witness. But she forgot to have a copy of the document available for the witness.

When Neumann had to interrupt her examination to ask her 35-person legal team to find another copy, it took a mind-numbing five minutes of frantic searching until one was discovered. In the meantime, Judge Kaplan fumed.

When Neumann gave another document to the witness, he mentioned that it had some writing in the margins from Chevron's own lawyers. The Chevron team then scrambled for a clean copy while about two dozen associates did nothing.

Judge Kaplan said: “Please Ms. Neumann, now really… I really don't expect to see this from lawyers of your caliber.”

While the Gibson Dunn army (at least 114 lawyers from the firm are on the case) tries to drown the plaintiffs in motions, only one lawyer can talk at a time in open court. That neutralizes Chevron's huge resource advantage when Mastro and Neumann are at the helm.

John Keker, the lawyer for Donziger, is a former Marine known for prosecuting and convicting Oliver North in the Iran contra scandal. Nobody on Chevron's team can come close to him in terms of intelligence, presence, and persuasiveness.

Judge Kaplan, not surprisingly, often tried to shut down Keker by calling him up for “sidebar” conversations that take place in whispers in front of the bench – a bizarre move indeed given that there was no jury around. It underscores just how much Kaplan plays to the gallery.

Judge Kaplan's challenge is to figure out how to keep Keker from getting his client a fair trial before a jury. That would be very risky bet for Chevron under any circumstances, but particularly with this duo running the show.

Mastro's bigger problem is that he has better political connections than trial skills. He served as Deputy Mayor to Rudy Guliani when the Mayor carried out a racially divisive political strategy, which Mastro helped him implement with evident gusto. His friends suggest he sees the Ecuador case as the pinnacle of his career.

Also of note is that Mastro's new star hire, former New York federal prosecutor Reed Brodsky, seems to be working as a junior law clerk on the Chevron trial team. In 2011, Brodsky used his formidable trial skills to win a conviction against hedge fund titan Raj Rajaratnam and parlayed that into a lucrative job under Mastro.

During the hearing, Brodsky was sitting next to Mastro and Neumann so he could pass notes and whisper in their ear. He never stood up to ask a question.

Ouch.

Monday, April 22, 2013

Harvard University Hosts Representatives of Ecuadorians with $19 Billion Judgment Against Chevron

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

Harvard University's Carr Center for Human Rights Policy is hosting representatives of the Ecuadorian indigenous groups who sued for and won a $19 billion judgment in Ecuador against Chevron for massive oil contamination.

They will discuss their two-decade effort to force Chevron to pay the judgment. Chevron has refused, defying the Ecuador courts even though Chevron promised to accept Ecuadorian jurisdiction when a U.S. federal judge and the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals transferred the lawsuit to Ecuador in 2001.

The Ecuadorians are aggressively seeking to seize Chevron's assets in three countries: Brazil, Argentina and Canada. Lawsuits have been filed in the three countries, and Argentina has frozen about $2 billion of Chevron's assets already.

Andres Snaider, an associate at Wilmer Cutler & Pickering and a Harvard University law graduate, and Chris Jocknick, director of the Private Sector Department for Oxfam America, will discuss the historic lawsuit and bring guests up to date on what is happening with the litigation.

Attendance is free. A flyer can be viewed here or downloaded here. Below are more details:

Wednesday April 24, 2013 - 4-6 pm
Carr Center Conference Room
Rubenstein 219
Harvard Kennedy School of Government

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

The Truth Behind the Stratus Affidavits

Scientific Evidence Against Oil Giant Remains Overwhelming

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

The Stratus affidavits did not change anything for Chevron's perilous legal position in the Ecuador environmental case where it faces a $19 billion liability, as well as asset seizure actions in Canada, Brazil, and Argentina.

In a classic misdirection move designed to distract attention from its liability, Chevron last week unveiled affidavits from two scientsts from Stratus Consulting who used to work for the Amazon communities that for almost 50 years have been victimized by the company's pollution. Chevron claimed the consultants, Douglas Beltman and Ann Maest, "disavowed" their involvement in the Ecuador litigation as well as the findings in a technical assessment known as the Cabrera Report that the Ecuador court did not even consider when finding the company liable.

These affidavits show just how limited the options for Chevron have become as it spends more and more money in an increasingly futile quest to escape accountability for its toxic dumping in the Amazon.

Chevron's fundamental problem is that Beltman and Maest are not telling the truth about the science behind the Ecuador case.

As background, Chevron aimed a figurative gun at the head of Stratus, where Beltman is a partner. The company faced bankruptcy just by having to defend itself against Chevron's 114-lawyer army at Gibson Dunn, which had named Stratus as a defendant in a highly questionable RICO case in New York.

Chevron had also waged a vicious campaign to persuade clients of Stratus to fire the company based on false allegations that the company had committed "fraud" in Ecuador. As part of the settlement it extorted, Chevron forced Beltman and Maest to abide by a gag order and agree not to work on projects involving Chevron for two decades.

The problem Beltman and Maest (and Chevron) now have is that the recent affidavits clearly contradict their earlier sworn testimony (available here and here) that concluded Chevron was responsible for massive pollution in Ecuador. A chart of how Beltman and Maest have flagrantly changed their testimony in the face of Chevron's threats can be found here.

Just weeks ago, in a legal filing, Stratus itself described the shakedown it was experiencing, saying Chevron has engaged in "an extrajudicial campaign of malicious defamation and deliberate interference with Stratus' business to tortuously destroy Stratus (and the livelihood of its employees)." Stratus made it clear in its court filings that it believed the Ecuador case was legitimate and based on valid scientific evidence. (See Stratus' Counterclaim against Chevron here)

Chevron is also trying to spin the affidavits to convince courts that the Amazon communities have "lost" the main source of their scientific data supporting the Ecuador judgment. Nothing could be further from the truth. Stratus played a major role in preparing materials for one technical report that the court threw out.

Stratus had nothing to do with any of the more than 100 other expert reports submitted as evidence that were relied on to find liability.

Stratus never produced a single one of the 64,000 chemical sampling results presented by the parties to the court that documented extensive pollution at 100% of Chevron's well sites in Ecuador. This data was produced by 23 court-appointed experts nominated by the parties that did not include Stratus.

The trial judge also pegged the majority of the remediation cleanup valuation figures to the work of Gerardo Barros, a court appointed expert who had been designated by Chevron. Chevron's argument that the process was "tainted" has not been accepted by any court in Ecuador, but as a practical matter the issue of what Stratus did in Ecuador with the Cabrera report is a nullity.

Apart from the prior sworn testimony of Beltman and Maest that proves the contentions of the communities, there is overwhelming scientific and testimonial evidence that documents Chevron's environmental abuses in Ecuador, where it operated from 1964 to 1992 under the Texaco brand.

For example:

  • Chevron's own internal audits, produced in the early 1990s as it was winding down its operations in Ecuador, documented pollution at each one of its drilling sites. They also found the company exercised no environmental controls in the 25 years it operated in Ecuador. (See the audits here and here)
  • During the trial, Chevron's own chemical sampling results (see this comparison chart compiled with data from the Ecuador trial) proved the claims of the plaintiffs.
  • Stratus itself documented the pollution in a devastating power point presentation that concluded 100% of the Chevron well sites in Ecuador tested during the trial had levels of toxicity that violated legal norms in the U.S.

Beltman said it best in a deposition taken by the Amazon communities on Sept. 9, 2011, on a date well before the effects of Chevron's extortion effort had fully kicked in. Beltman testified that the way Chevron operated in Ecuador was "substandard" and that "groundwater, streams, rainforest, wells and stations" were "all contaminated" by the company's operations.

Also on that day, again under oath, Beltman concluded that Chevron's claims that its "remediation" in Ecuador was effective are "false" and that he believes that "exposure to carcinogens caused by Texaco operations at least contributed to the higher rates of cancer."

If Beltman and Maest testify consistent with the recently extorted affidavits, they will look like liars. If a jury hears the earlier testimony under oath, which is corroborated by extensive evidence at trial, Chevron will (as it should) look terrible.

The bigger picture is that what Chevron does in a New York court has virtually no significance.

Courts in other countries being asked to enforce the judgment against Chevron assets, if anything, will recoil when asked to abide by any decision coming from a clearly biasd judge trying to give the oil giant a home court advantage. For an understanding of just how biased, read these mandamus petitions (here and here) asking for the reassignment of Judge Lewis A. Kaplan.

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals has set a date in May to consider that issue yet again, so it is unclear if the RICO trial will even get off the ground or if Chevron will blink when it comes time for a jury to hear even some of the awful facts relating to its criminal activity in Ecuador -- which includes attempted bribes of Ecuador's government to quash the case.

If anything, the New York proceeding before Judge Kaplan – like much else in this case – could easily boomerang against Chevron. Ditto for Beltman and Maest, who now have lost all credibility in the face of Chevron's pressure campaign that threatened their ability to earn a livelihood.

Stay tuned.

Friday, April 12, 2013

U.S. Appeals Court To Hear Request To Remove Biased Judge In Ecuador Case

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals – the same court that stopped cold Chevron's effort to block enforcement of the $19 billion Ecuador judgment in 2012 – has agreed to hear arguments by the Ecuadorians on why U.S. trial court judge Lewis A. Kaplan is continuing to engage in acts of insubordination from the bench.

The decision by the appellate court to hear the arguments is bad news for Kaplan, who already has been overturned once by the Second Circuit for imposing an unprecedented "global injunction” that purported to prohibit indigenous and farmer communities in Ecuador from enforcing a judgment from their own courts anywhere in the world. Kaplan had become the target of worldwide derision for trying to dictate rulings to the courts of other countries. (See press release here.)

The Ecuadorians say Kaplan's efforts to orchestrate a show trial warrant the reassignment of the case, as documented by this previous posting on The Chevron Pit.

Chevron is using the remaining fraud counts it filed against the Ecuadorians and their counsel to try to chill fundamental human rights advocacy that attempts to hold the oil giant accountable for its discharge of billions of gallons of toxic waste into the Amazon, as found by an Ecuadorian court based on overwhelming scientific evidence. Steven Donziger, a longtime American lawyer for the communities, has countersued Chevron for lying and engaging in fraud to cover up its misconduct. (See Donziger's counterclaims here.)

Chevron suffered a major setback recently when a California judge ruled that the environmental group Amazon Watch – known as Chevron's "sharpest critic” – was engaged in First Amendment-protected activity when it criticized the company for its refusal to clean up its contamination in Ecuador. Chevron had tried to subpoena the group's documents, claiming its advocacy was part of an improper pressure campaign. (See an article explaining the decision here.)

The Ecuadorians, meanwhile, have denied Chevron's outrageous charges. The company is desperate to distract attention from advancing seizure lawsuits targeting billions of dollars of assets in Canada, Brazil, and Argentina – with more such actions to come, according to lawyers for the communities.

Kaplan had shocked legal observers with his rants and prejudicial statements from the bench about Ecuador, a longtime U.S. ally where Chevron itself has won multiple lawsuits against the country's state-owned oil company. He derided Ecuador's government and judiciary. He refused to recognize the fundamental humanity of the impoverished indigenous victims, referring to them as the "so-called plaintiffs" and urging Chevron to file a racketeering and extortion case.  See this previous Chevron Pit.

To top it all off, Chevron lawyer Randy Mastro literally was laughed out of court when he couldn't answer fundamental questions before the appellate panel. See here. Mastro's effort to protect Kaplan was an utter failure.

Kaplan's tendency to engage in judicial imperialism has once again reared its ugly head. He is now setting up Chevron's so-called "RICO” case as nothing more than a show trial, stripping the ability of the plaintiffs to put on evidence of Chevron's toxic dumping and fraudulent cover-up while purporting to rule (in defiance of the earlier Second Circuit order) on the legitimacy of Ecuador's judiciary.

That's the same judiciary that Chevron praised when it fought for ten years to venue the trial there after the Ecuadorians originally filed the case in New York.

A trial by jury has been set by Kaplan for October 15th. But we say that neither Chevron nor Kaplan really have the guts to risk a full-blown trial before a jury where the truth can come out. Kaplan and Chevron will try to figure out a way to prevent jurors from hearing the case – possibly by dropping monetary claims for damages, thereby allowing a bench trial.  If jurors do hear the case, Kaplan won't let the Ecuadorians put on evidence of Chevron's crimes and fraudulent cover-up.

But wait – isn't a bench trial by Kaplan what the Second Circuit vacated the first time?

Kaplan and Chevron are now operating from a smaller and smaller box, with their options to impede a final recovery constricting almost weekly. Meanwhile, Mastro and his team of 114 lawyers at Gibson Dunn & Crutcher are on a roller coaster ride of unprecedented billing excess, subsidized by Chevron shareholders who themselves are being duped by Chevron management, as this devastating report by securities lawyer Graham Erion points out.

Gibson Dunn lawyers are laughing all the way to the bank while piling up a string of setbacks for their client, whose management is either too obtuse or personally conflicted to understand the peril they are facing.

In their petition, the Ecuadorians argue that in the earlier reversal the appellate court found that Kaplan did not have jurisdiction to rule on the Ecuador judgment unless the Ecuadorians sought to enforce the judgment in a New York court – a legal move that the Ecuadorians have not taken and have said they will not take. Yet Kaplan continues to claim in various rulings he can still so dictate, in defiance of the appellate court.

We remind Judge Kaplan of the words written by the Second Circuit in 2011:

"The (Ecuadorians) hold a judgment from an Ecuadorian court. They may seek to enforce that judgment in any country in the world where Chevron has assets. There is no indication that they will select New York as one of the jurisdictions in which they will undertake enforcement efforts . . . . It is unclear what is to be gained by provoking a decision about the effect in New York of a foreign judgment that may never be presented in New York. If such an advisory opinion were available, any losing party in litigation anywhere in the world with assets in New York could seek to litigate the validity of the foreign judgment in this jurisdiction. . . . Chevron can present its defense to the recognition and enforcement of the Ecuadorian judgment in New York if, as and when the (Ecuadorians) seek to enforce their judgment in New York."

Saturday, April 6, 2013

More Revelations About Chevron's Paid Witness & Its Miami Lawyer, Andres Rivero

Reposted from The Chevron Pit

Chevron not only is lying to a U.S. court about what happened in the historic Ecuadorian trial that the oil giant lost, it also offered a $1 million bribe to turn evidence against the Ecuadorians and their lawyers, testified an Ecuador judge in a legal declaration filed yesterday in the Southern District Court of New York.

Ecuador Judge Nicolás Zambrano, who found Chevron guilty in February 2011 of the world's largest oil-related environmental disaster, submitted the filing to a U.S. court, in response to false charges brought by Chevron that Zambrano allowed the Ecuadorians' lawyers to write his judgment for payment.

Zambrano said in his declaration that only he wrote the detailed 188-page ruling, documenting the extensive contamination of Chevron's substandard drilling and exploratory system wrought upon the environment and the impoverished indigenous people living near the pollution. Chevron has argued that Zambrano was incapable of writing such a judgment and has entered into evidence testimony by another judge, Alberto Guerra, that the real authors are the Ecuadorians' lawyers.

Only problem is Guerra has been paid at least $324,000 for his testimony and likely will be paid much, much more, given the unbelievable agreement Chevron has negotiated with Guerra, who now lives in Miami with his family and his son's family – all at Chevron's expense.

Importantly, Chevron's own lawyers have admitted that Guerra actually approached Chevron in 2009 about writing the judgment in its favor if they would pay him.

Not surprisingly, about that time, Guerra announced publicly that he thought the lawsuit against Chevron was not legitimate, even though the trial was underway.

Also underway at the same time was a Chevron sting operation to derail the trial by staging a phony bribery attempt against yet another judge who heard the case. It failed miserably, but Chevron spent much of the year organizing it and publicizing its sensational but false allegations of bribes.

At no time in 2009, 2010 and 2011, during years of hysterically wild accusations of corruption and fraud charged by Chevron, did the oil giant breathe a word about Guerra offering to write the judgment for Chevron for money.

If Chevron wanted to prove that the Ecuador courts were corrupt, here was its perfect opportunity. Yet, Chevron's lawyers, not known for avoiding a media interview in Quito, were silent.

Now Zambrano reveals that Guerra as Chevron's proxy approached him in August 2012 with an offer to turn evidence against the Ecuadorians' lawyers for $1 million or as much money as Zambrano might want.

Zambrano rejected the offer then and later avoided overtures in January 2013 by Chevron lawyer Andres Rivero who called Zambrano and urged a meeting. Zambrano refused.

The 20-year-old case, now being litigated to seize Chevron's assets in Brazil, Argentina, Canada and Ecuador as payment for the judgment, continues to take twists and turns in a U.S. court, both sides slinging charges fast and furious.

But, there are two charges that even Chevron cannot deny:

One: Chevron's man, Alberto Guerra, will say whatever the highest bidder pays.

And, two: Texaco, which Chevron bought, dumped 16 billion gallons of toxic water and oil directly into the rainforest waterways and built 900 unlined pits and filled them with pure crude that has leeched into soil and underground water – all because it wanted to save money. Chevron's company treated the rainforest like a garbage dump and its people as disposable as the toxic oil it left behind.